Haswell Creative — Case Study 20

Steadfast Plumbing · Home Services

Reliable, the headline said— the copy undercut it

Steadfast's whole pitch is in the name. Their old site had a typo in the navigation bar and grammatical errors in the very sentence promising reliability — a credibility gap no amount of good plumbing work could close on its own.

Role
Website redesign, UX, build
Year
2025
Deliverables
Identity refresh, responsive site, service pages, quote request form, reviews page
The Steadfast Plumbing homepage shown on a laptop and a phone, a photograph of a plumber working under a sink with the headline Your Reliable Plumber.
The navigation bar read Monu instead of Menu, and the subheading had a typo in the very sentence promising reliable service.

The problem

Steadfast had built fifteen years of genuinely reliable service — on-time arrivals, fair pricing, the kind of plumber people actually recommend. None of that reputation was reflected online. The site, thrown together quickly years earlier, had a misspelled nav item and a typo in its own tagline: the sentence meant to promise reliability had a grammatical error in it.

For a service business selling trust above all else, small errors like that do outsized damage. A homeowner deciding between three plumbers doesn't need much of a reason to move to the next tab, and sloppy copy is exactly that reason.

The business also had years of five-star reviews sitting on third-party platforms with no presence on the site itself — real social proof that a prospective customer would never see unless they went looking for it separately.


The approach

Three moves, in order.

01

Fix what ‘reliable’ was supposed to prove

Every line of copy was rewritten and proofread, closing the gap between the promise in the headline and the quality of everything underneath it.

02

Make the services and the request specific

Pipe Repair, Fixture Installation and Sewer Line Service replaced a generic paragraph, and the quote form now asks the issue type up front.

03

Bring the reviews home

A dedicated reviews page pulls the business's actual five-star history onto its own site, instead of leaving it scattered across platforms a visitor might never check.

The work

What we built.

The new homepage

The new Steadfast Plumbing homepage on desktop and mobile: a headline reading Fifteen years, done right, beside review cards showing five-star ratings.
The homepage, with the proof moved up. Fifteen years of five-star reviews in the hero — and every line proofread this time.
The services page: a three-card grid for Pipe Repair, Fixture Installation and Sewer Line Service, each with a line icon and short description.
Three services, spelled correctly and described plainly — a low bar, but one the old site didn't clear.
The request a quote page: a form with name, address, issue type dropdown and preferred date fields.
A quote request that captures the issue before the first call, not during it.
The customer reviews page: a three-column grid of review cards, each with a five-star rating, a short quote and a customer name.
Years of five-star reviews, finally visible on the business's own site instead of buried on a third-party platform.

Also delivered

A proofreading pass across every page and a simple internal style checklist, the same fix applied at Sterling & Co., since typo-driven credibility problems turned out to be more common across these client sites than any of us expected.

Results

First two quarters on the new site.

+53%

Quote requests submitted online

2.6×

Time spent on the reviews page

+21%

New customers citing reviews as a deciding factor

0

Typos left promising reliability

“We'd worked fifteen years to earn the name Steadfast and our own website had a typo in the tagline. Fixing that, and finally showing our reviews, made the site say what our customers already knew.”

Bruno AlcarazOwner, Steadfast Plumbing

Figures are illustrative of the outcomes this engagement was designed to produce and are shown here for portfolio purposes.